Tackling Structural Violence: A challenge for the post 2015 agenda

Tackling Structural Violence: A challenge for the post 2015 agenda

It is not difficult to see why the MDGs were hailed as a great blueprint for ‘development’; they are concise, measurable and adaptable, and most importantly they were signed by all the member states of the United Nations at the time. Paradoxically, the main reason for the belief in the MDGs is also their major weakness, and arguably of development projects in general. The focus on numbers, and individuals as numbers, tends to overshadow the unique and complex characteristics each person might bring to the table. This aspect is fundamental to development projects.  Furthermore, while these projects aim to tackle poverty, which causes suffering Paul Farmer has asked: how do we measure this suffering? How do we measure the indignity?

Development in its history has shown us that it is lopsided and that there has to be a strong, powerful ‘developer’ and the weak, powerless ‘developee’ for the relationship to continue. Furthermore, this relationship is not always contextualized to show their interconnectedness and heavy reliance on one another. For this piece, I will attempt to show that water, one of the most basic of all human rights, is one of the mirrors to this lopsided relationship and of growing inequalities. While some do not have clean water to drink, some enjoy access to swimming pools using thousands of liters, daily. These two extreme points about water are hardly contextualized as connected and never questioned as inequalities of privilege and how the global structure, violent in its nature, continues to perpetuate a world of winners and losers.

In Open Veins of Latin America, Eduardo Galeano posits that “the international division of labor, as it emerged along with capitalism, among nations is that some specialize in winning and others in losing.” Galeano adds that ” …the winners happen to have won thanks to [Latin America] losing: the history of Latin America’s underdevelopment is, as someone has said, an integral part of the history of world capitalism’s development” . The same applies to African countries. Walter Rodney’s How Europe Underdeveloped Africa, highlights the same arguments, stating that capitalism failed to change the social relations in Africa and the loss of power is a form of underdevelopment as countries lost the ability to defend their own interests. Thus while there are various historical precedents that demonstrate the legacy of underdevelopment, Paul Farmer in Pathologies of Power: Health, Human Rights and the New War on the Poor, argues that present day “social factors including gender, ethnicity (“race”), and socioeconomic status may each play a role in rendering individuals and groups vulnerable to extreme human suffering” (2003:42).

One of the ongoing stereotypical ‘jokes’ about ‘black’ people is that we do not swim. And in my experience it is true most of the black people I know personally indeed do not swim. Those who tell this joke annoy me a lot, as much as those who act surprised when they learn of an adult who cannot swim. This is because being able to swim can be situated in a much larger context to illustrate structural violence; how privilege, access, opportunity and bias work. Swimming is an instrument of structural violence. The first implicit bias of the joke is the singling out of one race. If you are from Botswana like me, and many other countries in Africa, many of the opportunities ‘available’ to us to learn to swim require a level of economic freedom/standing. The most common avenues are schools and hotels/lodges, and a few learn at home. Now both schools and hotels can only be accessed by families with resources and public schools do not have pools.

In my opinion, the ‘why blacks don’t swim’ debate should be contextualized within history and the realm of socio-economic rights. This is not to say that the act of swimming is itself a right, but rather to highlight that for most, not being able to exercise this ‘privilege’ is not a matter of choice. It is also worth noting that the idea of swimming in itself in this context has been limited to just pools and linked to socio economic status. This false construction does not take into account other places such as rivers and streams that black people also swim in. Furthermore, for those with access to pools, it has become a ‘positioned good’ marking an ‘arrival’ status. Due to limited access to these places to swim, social scarcity is created by not only the absolute physical limitations of pools but also limited access.

In a recent talk I attended by Dr. Wahbie Long he emphasized that social scientists are not used to explain the everyday realities of the working class as there continues to be an unwillingness to name the violence that exists. Though his talk was on African Psychology and South Africa, it remains relevant to all fields and other contexts. One of his main points, taken from Bulhan’s (1985) Frantz Fanon and the Psychology of Oppression, was that there needs to be a shift of focus from violence of intent to violence of consequence. In an email correspondence he gave the example that “when someone is underpaid for their labor, it’s not because the employer has the explicit intention of humiliating the worker – the intention is irrelevant. What matters are the violent consequences the worker experiences because of being underpaid: poverty, shame etc.” This shift will allow for a focus on structural violence and lead to a change in how “the system” works.

As we look toward the post 2015 agenda, and we especially focus on the ‘road to dignity’ it will be imperative to understand exactly how structures work and to place emphasis on how systems, and not people, work. This is because getting a better understanding of the structural dynamics will provide a better grasp on formulating a more holistic agenda. There is a need for a social justice agenda — looking beyond charity and development and focusing more on the injustices and inequalities that happen every day.

“A stand-alone water goal is critical as part of the Post-2015 Development Agenda” stated the World Water Council during an engaging year with UN institutions for the preparation of the Sustainable Development Goals (see this report). I hope this recommendation will be taken seriously, and take into account systemic factors.

MDG, Migration and Rising forms of Nationalism

MDG, Migration and Rising forms of Nationalism

Tweet By Patrick Litanga I am not offering answers; instead I am asking questions, perhaps unsettling ones. It is my contention that migration and rising forms of nationalisms were never seriously included in the MDG, especially in the African context. For instance, how do we productively address development goals in Tanzania without considering the fateContinue Reading

Setting an inclusive and pro-LGBTIQA post-MDG agenda

Setting an inclusive and pro-LGBTIQA post-MDG agenda

Tweet By: Gcobani Qambela* I really enjoyed the last weeks’ contribution to Bokamoso by Bradley W. Parks on “How journalism aids development” and especially the conclusion that “In order for the United Nations’ next development plan to succeed, we must find ways to make it mean something to more people”. In the case of theContinue Reading

How journalism aids development

Tweet By Bradley W. Parks There are many conversations that take place around the Millennium Development Goals, yet one crucial piece often missing from these discussions is an explicit call for a free and vibrant press. Part of the reason behind this is the fact journalism is not often seen as a contributor to development.Continue Reading

Sustainable Development Goals: Looking beyond the Millennium Development Goals

Tweet At the 2000 United Nation’s Millennium Summit, the Millennium Development Goals (MDG’s) were established. The summit concluded that the following goals were to be achieved by 2015; Eradicate extreme poverty and hunger Achieve universal primary education Promote gender equality and the empowerment of women Reduce child mortality Improve maternal health Combat HIV/AIDS, malaria andContinue Reading

My wish list for 2015

Tweet My hope for 2014 was that I learn to be my own leader and follower  and I would like to give myself a little pat on the back and say that I did manage to accomplish a little bit of it. During the year, we met regularly with new BLF members to discuss ‘TheContinue Reading

Broken and Bold: Love, loss and loneliness in Jozi

Broken and Bold: Love, loss and loneliness in Jozi

Tweet By: Gcobani Qambela* …to holding on, to knowing again that moment of rapture, of recognition, we can face one another as we really are, stripped of artifice and pretence, naked and not ashamed (from bell hooks, All about love: new visions)  I recently came across something that got me, it read: “I know whatContinue Reading

The Face of Fears: Blackness as a deadly weapon

The Face of Fears: Blackness as a deadly weapon

Tweet I think a lot about the jury statements after the George Zimmerman verdict.  One juror said: “Trayvon decided he wasn’t going to let him scare him and got the one-up on him. I think Trayvon got mad and attacked him [Zimmerman].”  Why does Trayvon’s possible anger result in someone needing to defend themselves toContinue Reading

On writing and clinging to my big girl panties

On writing and clinging to my big girl panties

Tweet By: Siphokazi Magadla “What was Shakespeare’s state of mind, for instance, when he wrote Lear and Antony and Cleopatra? It was certainly the state of mind most favourable to poetry that there has ever existed. But Shakespeare himself said nothing about it…Nothing indeed was ever said by the artist himself about his state ofContinue Reading

It Begins at Home- Empowering Women in Africa

Tweet So it looks like the African Union has declared 2015 as the year of women’s empowerment for, as we celebrate the Beijing Platform’s 20 year anniversary as well. Overall, I assume that we will be expected to assess progress, and chart a vision towards achieving gender equality in employment, access to resources, education andContinue Reading