Category Archives: Identity

Setting an inclusive and pro-LGBTIQA post-MDG agenda

Setting an inclusive and pro-LGBTIQA post-MDG agenda

By: Gcobani Qambela*

I really enjoyed the last weeks’ contribution to Bokamoso by Bradley W. Parks on “How journalism aids development” and especially the conclusion that “In order for the United Nations’ next development plan to succeed, we must find ways to make it mean something to more people”. In the case of the article by Parks, this means that there must be a vibrant and free press that will help aid development through rigorous reporting that will ultimately help keep government[s] in check. Parks’ article got me thinking about another issue that is often ignored in much of the thinking around the post-MDG agenda, and this being the issue of the rights of Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transexual, Intersex, Queer, and Asexual (LGBTIQA) persons, particularly in the African continent.

Earlier in the year I read an interesting article under the title “Why gay rights is a development issue in Africa, and aid agencies should speak up” by Hannah Stoddart. Stoddart, concerned with the very high rise in state sanctioned homophobia in Africa, shows how homosexuality in some African countries is often accompanied by a life sentence or up to twenty years in jail as nearly 37 African countries have outlawed homosexuality. Such outlawing is often accompanied by “increased threats and attacks against gay people – as has been the case in Uganda since the anti-gay law was introduced last year” writes Stoddart.

According to Stoddart, development agencies working in especially the “developing world” are often faced with a dilemma in that the presence of these organisations is “in many countries authorised by the same States that are preaching homophobia – but whose supporter-base by and large consists of liberal folk in the developed world who find homophobia distasteful.”

As a result of this dilemma, gay rights are often seen as a different category to other rights with many organisations remaining silent on the issue. Those who do decide to tackle the issue often do so under creative and euphemistic titles and language utilizing terms such as ‘at risk’ or ‘high-risk’ populations. It is in this fashion that Stoddart calls on us to “commit to lobbying donor governments to put pressure on recipient States who are criminalizing homosexuality” because it is important “for the sake of good, fair and equal development” that we “speak up.”

Just over a year ago, I conducted interviews for Stop Street Harassment with self-identified lesbian women in rural Peddie (Eastern Cape, South Africa). In the write up I remarked that “despite progressive same-sex legislation, [South Africa] still presents an extremely hostile environment for non-heterosexual sexualities.” Yet, beyond the reports of homophobia and ‘corrective rapes’ that saturate much of the South African public discourse, very little interrogation and investigation is paid to the ways in which social and state sanctioned anti-LGBTIQA sentiments also affect the development needs of such persons.

In speaking to many of the lesbian women, I saw that homophobia not only appeared to have psycho-social impacts, but also often affected many of their abilities for livelihood and shaped some of their migrational patterns in various and often detrimental ways.  This is not a new observation, per se. Jessica Horn in her talk “Can aid donors help support LGBT rights in developing countries?” notes that the choice to discriminate on any basis is always a political choice. She says that it is political in two senses: firstly, in the sense that as humans we are always choosing ethically to navigate the questions of power and authority “and how we manage collective life”. And the second sense referring to the political choices we make especially in reference to party politics.

Horn says that it is important to expand the debates and attempts to “narrow spaces around sexual orientation and gender identity” because such efforts are part of broader heterosexist gender norms that want to maintain a particular type of social system of patriarchy in place. In this view, it is no coincidence that a lot of the anti-homosexuality legislations accompany the backlash against other various forms of challenges to patriarchy including challenges on marital rape, the prioritization of women’s economic justice and resistance against restrictive gender norms.

Horns notes that in countries where there is anti-homosexuality legislation tabled, that legislation often goes side to side with legislation that criminalises the dress codes of women, legislation that censors the use of pornography, regulates the sexual and reproductive body and generally a lot of other measures of containment (that are for the most part fueled by ‘the religious right’).

What is also concerning to Horn is also the often ignored party politic element to state sanctioned homophobia where governments play on “presumed national homophobia” to garner support for anti-LGBT policies. In this process governments are able to create a distraction around “other” issues by creating a diversion where LGBT(IQA) individuals are used for a “scapegoating exercise”. Under such conditions, dissent becomes criminalized with ultra-surveilled with various penalisations that infringe people’s freedom of association. Horn concludes that issues pertaining to LGBT(IQA) therefore are not only about “a question of identity… [they are] economic, social and political struggles… and queer Africans are facing poverty; [lack of] education, lack of water, healthcare issues…”

As we start unpacking the “post-MDG agenda”, I strongly believe that an inclusive post-MDG agenda is one that also makes specific measures in place to accommodate the social, economic and political needs of LGBTIQA persons in both the African continent, and globally. This, I believe will be the first step in creating an intersectional, inclusive and accepting world where difference are not a means for exclusion, but the entry point to connecting people across gender and sexuality.

Gcobani Qambela is a regular Bokamoso contributor. Read his previous articles here.

A reflection on Ferguson

A reflection on Ferguson

Tweet by Merrian Brooks  I have a lot of feelings about the protests symbolized by Ferguson. Watching TV news the day after the Grand Jury decision, I thought I’d had enough. Watching the news and way they sensationalized the riots showing images of black rage over and over again started to sicken me. But I… Continue Reading

Exploring Racism and Sports in Europe: Individual and institutional actions and non-actions in sports stadiums

Exploring Racism and Sports in Europe: Individual and institutional actions and non-actions in sports stadiums

Tweet by Gerard Akindes and Sessi Aboh Of course no one organization can solve this problem. Everyone involved, including the clubs, fans, players, police and those responsible for stewarding, has a responsibility here (UEFA President and CEO) In stadiums throughout Europe, Black athletes are made to bear the indignities and humiliations of racial abuse. Racial… Continue Reading

Identity and School Attainment

Identity and School Attainment

Tweet There are many theories about black American educational attainment as attempts are made to look for interventions to close the ‘achievement gap’ between underrepresented minority students and their white counterparts. A brief review of the statistics shows that all minority groups are not created equal with black and Hispanic students faring much worse than… Continue Reading

To Dress “African” or Not: the politics behind a personal “rational” choice

To Dress “African” or Not: the politics behind a personal “rational” choice

Tweet By: Emmanuelle Adjima Assy* Needless to say, first impressions do matter.  Human beings seem to be sociologically modeled to judge a book by its cover when it comes to social interactions. The fact is that any form of non verbal communication and exterior appearances constitute a distinctive way to self introduce to others before spoken… Continue Reading

Father’s eye view: four months with my daughter Nyathira

Father’s eye view: four months with my daughter Nyathira

Tweet By: George Gathigi* Before I became a father, I remember hearing about how much ‘babies change your life.” Well, no big news there, I always thought, there has to be an obvious change when you get a baby; given that parents are required to assume the obligation of nurturing a new member of society.… Continue Reading

Ties that Bind: Could Tradition and Culture Bridge the Gap Between the Personal and Political?

Ties that Bind: Could Tradition and Culture Bridge the Gap Between the Personal and Political?

Tweet By: Doreen Gaura* In spite of the progress that has been made thus far regarding public policy and legislation to ensure gender equality and bodily integrity in a lot of Southern [1] Afrikan countries there continues to be a barricade impeding the smooth flow of these policies from the public/ political space into people’s personal… Continue Reading

South African reflections on #BlackPowerIsForBlackMen: Unpacking the silence of (Black) South African men on the war on queer bodies

South African reflections on #BlackPowerIsForBlackMen: Unpacking the silence of (Black) South African men on the war on queer bodies

Tweet By: Gcobani Qambela* and Thoko Sipungu**   … evil has a blockbuster audience, goodness lurks backstage. Evil has vivid speech, goodness bites its tongue” –  Toni Morrison. Writing for The Guardian, Mikki Kendall, writes that she started #SolidarityIsForWhiteWomen out of a frustration in noting multiple ways in which the voices of women of color… Continue Reading

All struggles are connected: The intersections of the political

All struggles are connected: The intersections of the political

Tweet By: Camalita Naicker* During the Rape Crisis Teach-in held by the Rhodes University Politics Department in Grahamstown this July, South African historian and researcher Dr Catherine Burns, brought up a little known event that happened in Soweto in February 1990. Mary Mabaso had organised an anti-rape march to draw attention to the increase in… Continue Reading

Educated Black Women: modern society’s ‘outliers’

Educated Black Women: modern society’s ‘outliers’

Tweet By: Thembani Mbadlanyana* Today, research shows that women, worldwide, earn almost 60 per cent of all bachelor’s degrees and more than half of masters and doctoral degrees. Associated with this growing bulge of educated women are questions around their marital prospects. Many research studies that have been conducted in this area have tried to… Continue Reading