Category Archives: Sports

Exploring Racism and Sports in Europe: Individual and institutional actions and non-actions in sports stadiums

Exploring Racism and Sports in Europe: Individual and institutional actions and non-actions in sports stadiums

by Gerard Akindes and Sessi Aboh

Of course no one organization can solve this problem. Everyone involved, including the clubs, fans, players, police and those responsible for stewarding, has a responsibility here (UEFA President and CEO)

In stadiums throughout Europe, Black athletes are made to bear the indignities and humiliations of racial abuse. Racial attitudes toward black athletes seem to be part of the football fabric in European leagues. In this atmosphere, athletic prowess or misses incite intense hatred inducing verbal abuse and physical threats.  Players of African descent are often confronted with a barrage of racial abuse, monkey chants and banana peels used as projectiles doubled as insults.

On Saturday, February 26, 2006, Samuel Eto’o from Cameroon, playing for FC Barcelona, overwhelmed by racial epithets and abuses threatened to leave the pitch during a game against Zaragoza, also in Spain.  The incident drew major media attention because Eto’o is a well renowned player.  In 2013, Kevin Prince Boateng, a German born player of Ghanaian descent also walked off the pitch during a game under similar circumstances. Furthermore, on May 13, 2013, Kevin Prince Boateng, Mario Balotelli, and other black players such as the Ghanaian Suley Muntari endured racial abuse from a group of AS Roma supporters during an Italian Série A game in Milan.  This past summer, Seydou Keita, a Malian player refused to shake hands with Pepe, a Portuguese player after a friendly game in Dallas, TX.  Pepe in retaliation spat on Keita who then threw a water bottle at him. This incident stemmed from a previous encounter between the two players when Pepe had called Keita a monkey years before when they both played in Spain. The episode was reported by Radio France International[1] and got some media coverage but less than a similar incident would have generated if it had occurred during a more mediatized game or competition. High profile leagues, teams, players and more importantly the global live broadcasting of the games have helped expose racist incidents and made it harder for all to ignore or deny them. But for all the media and live coverage of games, most racist incidents and abuses would still remain as localized anomalies or unverified anecdotes. Indeed, in less mediatized European leagues in Eastern Europe for instance, the overt abuse of black players and other nonwhite European minority players is only episodically reported.  This is particularly true for lower division clubs that do not receive as much media attention.

Racial slurs and threats are then often trivialized, denied, and/or swept under the rugs as attacked players develop or are proposed coping mechanisms to safeguard their careers. Denial and other coping mechanisms are one of the insidious characteristics of contemporary racism within the elite and educated populations.  Utterances such as “I’m not racist, I have black friends, I hang out with blacks” are common among individuals trying to defend themselves against the racist label. Luis Aragon’s[2] (a coach from Spain) illustrated the individual denial as well as the public denial.  “I cannot understand when I have gypsy, yellow, black friends, this is not me”[3] exclaimed a visibly outraged and offended Luis Aragon in 2004 when he was confronted with the racist remarks he made about Thierry Henry. The Spanish Federation added insult to injury by publicly denying the importance of the episode and by leveling a fine of $5,000 on Aragon. Furthermore, they allowed him to coach the Spanish national team a few months later into the FIFA World Cup.  In another incident, when supporters of a Montenegro team targeted Beasley, an African America player with their monkey chants, Veselin Tomovic said the monkey chants were common among the Montenegro fans and were not specifically aimed at Beasley. “Our fans chant that to their opponents all the time, it has nothing to do with the color of skin,” he said. With African players in search of a career in Europe, the denial and trivialization of racism in football can be a strategic choice towards achieving their professional ambitions. For most of the first generation immigrant players in search of a career, the investment and high expectations of their families in Africa encourage a passive response.  They were not organized nor did they have the political ability to protest against racist abuse or contest the denials of their unpleasant experiences.

With the growing number of a second generation of immigrants, players of African and Caribbean descent brought anti-African racism to the forefront of European societies. Overt racism against second generation immigrant players (most of them born and raised in Europe) is much more difficult to carry out as was the case with the game between England’s national team and Spain in November 17, 2004[4], where the abuse appeared to be more of an attack on European teams.  UEFA President Lennart Johansson and Chief Executive Gerhard Aigner offered the following statement:

The problem of racism is a real issue for the European football family and for the image of football in general […] Of course racism at our games is a sad reflection of society in general, but, because of the high-profile nature of football on our continent, we have a particular responsibility to take steps to stamp it out and prevent it occurring in the future.

In addition, over the years, the global media coverage of European major leagues helped bring to light racism in football and several organizations have started to openly address the issue.  FIFA officially started to tackle the race issue right before the 2006 World Cup. In conjunction with UNICEF, FIFA launched the “No To Racism” campaign during the 2006 World Cup. On March 16, 2007, FIFA also launched “Show Racism the Red Card” that symbolically means the expulsion of racism from the game. In addition, strong actions and policies were put in place to fight racism in football. In FIFA’s disciplinary code, Article 58[5], has six paragraphs of policies against racism. The FIFA “Say No to Racism” banner has become a common pregame image for FIFA competitions. Racism is openly discussed and integrated into media campaigns for international federations. UEFA “No To Racism”; FIFA “Say No To Racism”; and Corporations such as Nike’s “Stand Up Speak Up”[6] are examples of institutional actions against racism. Organizations such a Football Against Racism in Europe (FARE)[7] have also become important actors in campaigns against racism and discrimination.

Despite the aggressive anti-racism campaigns, external factors seem to temper real progress and changes.  Thus, the rise of extreme right political parties in European countries has reinvigorated shameless xenophobic and racial discourses on the public stage. Former France president Nicola Sarkozy and British Prime minister Gordon Brown for instance, chose to glorify the “civilizing” mission and accomplishment of their nations’ colonial ideologies. Also, despite fines, suspensions and increasing media attention, negative stereotypes as vestiges of racism in football are often expressed and maintained through popular culture, the media, and the arts.

Thankfully, racism in football seems to no longer be taboo and with wide demographic changes, the denial of racism in the sport has become more difficult. As stated before, the second generation of players of African origin is European and is less likely to accept and/or accommodate slurs and racist attacks. After all, as they play, more and more as integral parts of European national teams, insulting them equates to insulting European national teams. The ethnic frontiers associated with racial differences do not hold anymore and the player of African descent is no longer completely the “Other”. It would however be naïve to expect that football can singlehandedly change European societies and how they relate to the African “Other.” As stated by Gerard Dreyfus, a French journalist, “we cannot ask football to solve societies’ problems. However football is contributing to confronting the ugliness of racism and discrimination in Europe.” We ignore or deny everything around us yet when it happens in a stadium it’s become visible and claimed unacceptable. The construction of the Black as the “Other” closer to the monkey than the human has been disseminated consistently for centuries. Despite many efforts to deconstruct such design, countless well spread images and discourses about being black across the globe sustain the status of black people as the “Other”. It will take a major philosophical revolution of the dominant global-media and all societies to honestly start debunking the centuries-long ideological and philosophical construction of the African and the less than human status of individuals of African descent. Football and sport in general may contribute to the transformation, but will not achieve it.

References


[1] Seydou Keita: «c’est inacceptable qu’un autre homme me crache dessus »  http://www.rfi.fr/afrique-foot/20140730-seydou-keita-est-inacceptable-autre-homme-me-crache-dessus/?ns_campaign=reseaux_sociaux&ns_source=FB&ns_mchannel=social&ns_linkname=editorial&aef_campaign_ref=partage_aef&aef_campaign_date=2014-07-30

[2] http://www.telegraph.co.uk/sport/football/international/2387995/Spain-coach-in-the-dock-over-Henry-race-slur.html

[3] Id.

[4] http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport2/hi/football/internationals/4018421.stm

[5] http://www.fifa.com/mm/document/affederation/administration/fifa_dc_en_34118.pdf

[6] http://nikeinc.com/news/thierry-henry-and-fellow-players-call-on-fans-to-fight-racism

[7] http://www.farenet.org/

A conversation with myself: What if I ran for president?

A conversation with myself: What if I ran for president?

Tweet This conversation with myself started at the end of the 2012 London Olympics. Nigeria had just failed to win any medals in the Olympic Games for the first time since Seoul 1988, even though 55 competitors represented the country in the Games. The United States and China won 104 and 88 medals respectively toContinue Reading

Portraits of Olympic Dreams Running out of Africa

Portraits of Olympic Dreams Running out of Africa

Tweet Twice this year, the Olympic stadium in London stood on its feet and cheered Mo Farah as he crossed the finish line. The gold medal winner of the Men’s 5,000 and 10,000 meters made his country proud, and instantly he became a hero because no British man had ever won any of those twoContinue Reading

‘Exiled’ African Athletes, Career and Sport Citizenship Challenge

‘Exiled’ African Athletes, Career and Sport Citizenship Challenge

Tweet by Gerard Akindes In their slide show In pictures: Africa’s exiled Olympians[i] , BBC Africa highlights some African-born elite athletes who will be representing non-African nations at the London Olympic games in 2012. On a similar note, prior to the 26th African Cup of Nations in 2008, BBC Sport presented a comparable article TheContinue Reading

Sports as the new platform for development: New route, old paradigm?

Tweet The United Nations declaration of 2005 as the International Year of Sport and Physical Education marked a significant step in the connection of sports to international development. This forward looking milestone had the effect of bringing sports and physical activities to the global stage whilst recognizing its potential of mass mobilization. Specifically, the endorsementContinue Reading

Reflections on the Autobiography of Kwame Nkrumah

Tweet In the Winter Quarter of 2010, Bokamoso Leadership Forum members read through The Autobiography of Kwame Nkrumah. A couple of articles will be dedicated to reflections by the members on the ideas stuck out to them in the book. We would love for you to join in the conversation by posting commentsBose MaposaStemming fromContinue Reading

Morocco: Better luck in 2030

Tweet In the minds of South Africans, May 15th 2006 is synonymous with great achievement and is a warm-up for a giant leap towards a global event: The 2010 World Cup. However, in the minds of Moroccans, this particular day may not make any sense for some while it may give a feeling of inferiorityContinue Reading

International relations and diplomacy: Reflections on SA 2010 and the power of sports

Tweet by Kombe Kapatamoyo a former graduate student at Ohio University. Kombe is currently a PhD student at West Virginia University. The World Cup next year will be South Africa’s largest sports event. It will not only bring many nations together in one part of the world, but the world’s attention will be focused onContinue Reading

South Africa 2010 World Cup Preliminary Groups

Tweet The groups for the preliminary round of the World Cup have been selected and the groups are as follows Group A South Africa Mexico Uruguay France Group B Argentina Nigeria South Korea Greece Group C England USA Algeria Slovenia Group D Germany Australia Serbia Ghana Group E Netherlands Denmark Japan Cameroon Group F ItalyContinue Reading

In Semenya’s shoes: The deconstruction and reconstruction of gender and sexuality

Tweet by Bose Maposa and Siphokazi MagadlaFor any track and field athlete, the World Championships are the main event, the center stage to prove their worth in the world league and claim their place amongst the greatest. Qualifying to attend these games is an honor in itself; winning a medal a glory; whilst a goldContinue Reading